发信人: bongbongcat (土猫棒棒), 信区: Biology
标 题: Re: Any chance left?
发信站: Unknown Space - 未名空间 (Wed Sep 8 20:24:32 2004) WWW-POST

这个东西很难说，只有自己衡量着办。永远都是速度与质量的较量。不过要我说无论如何
不能投jbc。不是说jbc不好，而是被cell 送去review的东西，怎么着都是很有质量的，
投jbc太亏了。

我自己的故事说给你听：投了一个journal，被打回来。怕不行，转投另一个档次低点的
，结果打了6个月的持久站，来回拉锯4,5次，修改增加无数数据，终于接受。在长舒口气
的同时也不由得wonder:如果把后来这些都算上，兴许头一个高点档次的也搞定了？

所以呀，还是尽可能的投高点吧。其实要我说，一旦有review回来，而且不是直接句的，
接受的可能就已经很大了。comments不是每个都要满足的，只要满足一定数量，别的要有
理由的拒绝就可以了。

当然还有个考虑是你自己的打算。如果就想混个paper毕业无妨。如果这个paper对你以后
生涯很重要，还是越高越好。

good luck.




【 在 windysea (雨瞳~甜心小猪) 的大作中提到: 】
: I recenly sumitted my first paper to Cell,
: (my boss never published in Cell, he previously went mainly for Nature
series
: and Science)
: and today we got 10 pages of comments from 3 reviewers, with dosens of
points
: from each one, in front of which the editor says "significant further work
: would be necessary to support definitive conclusions" and gives us only 2
: months.
:
: my boss said he never saw so many comments, and it's almost impossible we
can
: make it, plus a couple of days ago one PNAS paper came out, which might
: partially damage our conceptual novelty, although about totally paralell
: subject and not contradicting with our story. my boss said that we need to
: move fast, and we could go for EMBO.J etc but may still get tons of
comments,
: and that JBC may be safe to go.
:
: Anybody would share experience of publishing and give some advice?
:
:
:

--
快乐是我的盔甲，思念是我的生涯。
我拥抱漆黑的空气，权当是你。
※ 来源:．Unknown Space - 未名空间 mitbbs.com．[FROM: 68.80.]