发信人: puppeteer (减肥中的河马), 信区: Biology
标 题: Re: Please give me some suggestions
发信站: Unknown Space - 未名空间 (Sun Nov 14 23:48:28 2004) WWW-POST

yes, the editor decides. reviewers only suggest opinions. Editor usually takes
scientific questions of reviewers seriously like whether there is a hole
somewhere. But regarding novelty etc, the editor has final deciding power.
【 在 CeliaCai (CeliaCai) 的大作中提到: 】
: So what is the deciding factor? Do those editors have that power?
: can anybody talk about his experience?
:
: My labmate(an American) got his paper into PRL with 1 yes 3 no( 2 no
: for 1st submit, 1yes1no fro 2nd)! I'm wondering if i'm in his position,
: whehter i'm able to get it in .
:
: 【 在 zzzzh (一切靠自己) 的大作中提到: 】
: : the decision of acceptance or not is not simply by vote.
:
:
:
:

--
大肚能容，容天下难容之事；
开口便笑，笑世间可笑之人。
※ 来源:．Unknown Space - 未名空间 mitbbs.com．[FROM: 172.128.]